X.C. Game Shop - Burley, Idaho

Jason T.

I recently visited this card shop and overall had a positive experience, though it was a bit of a mixed bag in some areas.

Pros:

Heidi was helpful, knowledgeable, and low-pressure—which I really appreciated. She took her time reviewing my trade-in cards and helped me find exactly what I was looking for.

Anna was also working that day and was very friendly and easy to talk to. I actually enjoyed chatting with her the most, even though she wasn’t as familiar with Pokémon cards.

The store had a wide variety of products and offered trade-ins at around 50% of TCGPlayer market value (for store credit). I calculated this myself after the fact.

Single card prices were very reasonable—within about 5% of TCGPlayer pricing. I bought five singles and thought the pricing was spot-on.

Cons:

Sealed product pricing was inconsistent. Some items were at or near market value (like the Shrouded Fable booster bundle at $35), but others were significantly higher—for example, a Surging Sparks booster pack was listed at $11, which is about 75% above market. Just something to be aware of.

One of the singles I bought had 4–5 noticeable print lines that I didn’t catch at the time because I was in a hurry. It’s on me for not double-checking, but next time I’ll be more careful.

I also traded in some cards with them, but as a newer customer, I would’ve appreciated a breakdown showing each card’s individual value instead of just getting the total sum. Something like a printed sheet or itemized list would go a long way toward building trust and helping newcomers understand the process better. All I was given was a sum and didn't get to see how they were calculating the values and what they could offer. Ideally a sheet would be given to a customer stating, here's what you have and here is what we can pay compared to market value. Its ok that they only offer 50% store credit, but being transparent and up front about it would be helpful as I know they have to run a business.

That said, I have a lot of sympathy for the owners and employees. The Pokémon market is unpredictable right now, and I can tell they’re doing their best to keep up and make things work for both collectors and the shop.

In the end, I’d give them a solid 3.5 stars if I could, but I’m rounding up to 4 because of the employees efforts and singles prices. If I come back it will be with a more careful eye next time before I buy cards. If the owner was present which according to the employees is less often than not, I may have had a different experience, but just wanted to make them aware of my experience.

Aaron R.

The most competitive prices in Burley that is not a big box store. The stock is really good and the staff very friendly. I'm trying to get into Pokemon so I will be back but don't be shy because they are really nice here. I know I will be back when I have more time.

Takado T.

I love this place. Very nice owner. Has one of the most organized selection of pokemon and yugioh cards I have ever seen. Trying to upgrade your deck? You can get just about any single you need at a good and fair price. There has never been much of a place in town to play either so I am also grateful for that. I would love to see this place grow, and will continue to go and try to support them.

zack S.

Very organized card shop. Owners are kind and super friendly! Stop by for a Pokémon tournament sometime!

Spookie's G. N. C.

Overpriced cards, won't honor the sticker price either

H M.

Coolest Pokemon shop I have ever been to

Ken J.

Very friendly and helpful. Great selection.

Juan L.

It’s a great place to buy and play!